By CHET McNULTY
Senior Basement League Insider
BASEMENT LEAGUE HQ: Five weeks down, nine to go, one trophy.
Nobody is undefeated. Two teams are 4-1. Eight of the other ten are sitting at 3-2 or 2-3, which, as the Commissioner pointed out to this desk on Wednesday with actual research attached, is the exact neighborhood that has produced most of the trophies in this building. Sunday gave us a 164.4, a 71-point beating, a quarterback who finished with negative points for a team that owns Patrick Mahomes, and twelve kickers who nearly doubled up twelve defenses. The league averaged 129.07 and it still felt like a week where half of you found out something you did not want to know.
WEEK 5 SCOREBOARD
League average 129.07
Jahmyr Gibbs 37.7, Christian Watson 32.3, Malik Nabers 29.1
Isaiah Likely 32.4, Bucky Irving 31.5, Brissett 25.28
Jayden Daniels 32.26, George Pickens 28.0, Goff 28.94 in a loss
Puka Nacua 37.7, Josh Allen 30.5, Stafford 27.32 in a loss
Jaylen Warren 36.8 in a loss, Parker Washington 30.4, Bowers 23.0
Drake Maye 39.46 in a loss, LaPorta 19.8, Drake London 18.8
STANDINGS · THROUGH WEEK 5
Record, then points for
#TeamRecPoints
11
HOPE IS COMING
1-4
533.84
12
HOUSE OF WENKE
1-4
491.88
Research · Provided by the Commissioner
THE COMMISSIONER'S NUMBER
Credit where it belongs. This is not my work. The Commissioner pulled the five-week record of every Basement League championship team in the fourteen-year history of this league and sent it to the press table unprompted, which is more original research than anyone else in this building has produced all season.
1-4
no champion has ever started here
0-5
no champion has ever started here
Read one. No Basement League champion has ever started worse than 2-3. Fourteen titles, fourteen teams at .400 or better after five weeks. Hope is Coming and House of Wenke are both 1-4. There is no precedent for either of them, and I am not going to pretend otherwise just because one of them is the defending champion.
Read two. 4-1 is the best seat in the building and it is not the building. Five of fourteen, from a bucket that usually holds two or three teams in any given year. The Wolfhounds and Kraemerica are splitting it this season.
Read three, and this is the one that matters most to the most of you. 2-3 has produced four champions. 3-2 has produced four champions. Those two buckets together account for eight of the fourteen trophies ever handed out here, and right now they contain eight of the twelve teams in this league. The Bruisers, Old School, Bridge Four and Zaddy should read that twice before they do anything rash.
One housekeeping note. The Commissioner is 4-1. He sent the press a statistic establishing that 4-1 is the most common championship start. I have filed it as research and not as a press release. But I want the record to show that I noticed.
THE SCHEDULE IS NOT A SKILL
Here is the number that reorganized how I see this league. CKWade03 has allowed 477.46 points in five weeks. The Brooklyn Bruisers have allowed 679.94. That is a gap of 202.48 points between the easiest road in this league and the hardest, which works out to just over forty points a week, which is roughly the entire weekly output of a good quarterback.
Nobody chose that. It is the schedule. But it is sitting underneath every record on the board and it deserves to be said out loud.
THE LEDGER · FIVE WEEKS
Sorted by point differential
TeamForAgainstDiff
CKWADE
605.86
477.46
+128.40
WOLFHOUNDS
666.56
538.66
+127.90
KRAEMERICA
632.02
557.30
+74.72
FELLOWSHIP
652.38
601.92
+50.46
OLD SCHOOL
600.54
555.24
+45.30
SCALABRINE
624.84
619.02
+5.82
BRUISERS
622.46
679.94
-57.48
BRIDGE FOUR
555.54
644.22
-88.68
HOPE IS COMING
533.84
650.64
-116.80
HOUSE OF WENKE
491.88
615.82
-123.94
CKWade03 leads this league in point differential and sits fifth. That is the entire story of his season in one line. He has scored the sixth-most points and faced the fewest by sixty one, and the result is a plus 128.40 that edges out the Wolfhounds for the best mark in the league. Whether you read that as a good team being politely handled by the calendar or a lucky team pretending, the differential is real and the 164.4 on Sunday was not an accident.
The Bruisers rank fifth in points scored and ninth in point differential, and the whole distance between those two numbers is who the schedule put across from them. 622.46 points scored is fifth in the league and more than two of the six teams currently holding a playoff spot. They are 2-3. They are not a 2-3 roster.
And at the bottom, no excuses available. Hope is Coming has been outscored by 116.80. House of Wenke by 123.94. Those two are not victims of the calendar. Those two are last on merit.
THE CHURN INDEX
New feature, and I suspect it is going to live here for the rest of the season. Every roster move each of you has made, lined up against what it bought.
THE CHURN INDEX
Roster moves against record
TeamMovesRec
The three quietest teams in this league, Scalabrine at three moves and Kraemerica and the Bruisers at four, are a combined 9-6. The three busiest, Bridge Four and Hope is Coming at fifteen apiece and CKWade03 at twelve, are a combined 6-9. An exact mirror, which I did not arrange and could not have.
The Wolfhounds are the honest counterexample at eleven moves and a 4-1 record, so this is a tendency rather than a law. But there is a difference between maintenance and panic. Eleven moves on a team that drafted well is upkeep. Fifteen moves on a 1-4 team that just lost its fourth straight is something else.
"The waiver wire is not a strategy. It is a receipt."
ONE MAN, FORTY-THREE PERCENT
Drake Maye threw for 39.46 on Sunday, the highest individual score anyone posted in Week 5. Zaddy scored 91.96 as a team, the second-lowest total in the league, and lost by 15.84 to a team that managed 107.8. One quarterback accounted for 42.9 percent of an entire roster's output.
The supporting cast: Jeremiyah Love 2.2, Cam Skattebo 7.1, George Kittle 7.4, Jakobi Meyers 5.7, and a Colts defense that finished at minus 1.0. The two starting running backs produced 9.3 points between them. On the bench sat Josh Jacobs, Kyle Monangai, Tyler Allgeier and Brian Robinson Jr., who produced 5.2 more. That is six running backs for 14.5 points, with a seventh on injured reserve.
You cannot win a week this way and you cannot fix it on a Tuesday. There are only so many running backs in the world and this roster has most of the wrong ones.
THE KICKERS BEAT THE DEFENSES
Twelve kickers combined for 144.0 points on Sunday. Twelve defenses combined for 78.0. The slot everybody drafts last and never thinks about again nearly doubled up the slot everybody streams on a hunch.
Jason Myers put up 23.0 for the Bruisers. Spencer Shrader 21.0 for Old School, Ka'imi Fairbairn 17.0, Will Reichard 16.0, Tyler Loop 14.0. Meanwhile the Bills finished at minus 3.0, the Cowboys at minus 2.0, the Colts at minus 1.0. The Bruisers started a kicker worth 23.0 and a defense worth minus 3.0 in the same lineup, a 26-point spread between the two roster spots nobody takes seriously.
I am not telling you to draft a kicker in the tenth round. I am telling you that the spread between the best kicker and the worst defense on Sunday was 26 points, which is larger than the final margin in two of the six games played.
THE SELLERS' MARKET
By the Commissioner's own numbers, no team in the history of this league has won it after starting 1-4. That makes Hope is Coming and House of Wenke the first two sellers of 2026, and it makes the other ten of you buyers whether you have admitted it to yourselves or not. This is the first week all season that the trade market has a real shape to it.
What Hope is Coming has to move: Justin Jefferson, Lamar Jackson, Marvin Harrison Jr., and a Jaylen Warren who went for 36.8 on Sunday. Note that they started Brock Purdy over Lamar Jackson this week. The owner has already told you where his head is.
What House of Wenke has to move: Kyren Williams, D'Andre Swift, Omarion Hampton, Michael Pittman Jr., Stefon Diggs, Mark Andrews, and a backup quarterback in Jordan Love who scored 25.28 from the bench while Matthew Stafford started and won the position outright.
CALL ONE
CKWade03 sends Blake Corum and Jordan Addison · Hope is Coming sends Lamar Jackson
The best point differential in the league belongs to a team that started Sam Darnold for 8.3. There is exactly one hole on that roster and it has been the same hole since September. Across the table is a 1-4 team with a spare former MVP sitting behind the quarterback it actually starts. If Hope is Coming says no, raise it until they say yes, because the alternative is finishing fifth with the best point differential in the league and a quarterback nobody wanted.
CALL TWO
Bridge Four sends Garrett Wilson · House of Wenke sends Kyren Williams
Bridge Four scored 89.2 on Sunday and started Tyjae Spears and Will Shipley at running back for a combined 18.1. Saquon Barkley is not walking through that door this week. House of Wenke is 1-4, last in the league in points scored, and holding more backs than any lineup can use while Courtland Sutton and Malik Washington produce 21.9 between them at receiver. Garrett Wilson went for 23.4 on Sunday. One of these teams has a hole and the other has a pile, and both of them are running out of season.
THE BUBBLE
Six spots, twelve teams, nine games left. Here is where the model has everybody this morning.
Everything that matters lives in that run from 52 down to 38. Five teams, fourteen points of probability, four of them carrying identical 2-3 records and one of them riding a three-game winning streak straight into the middle of it. HaHa holds the sixth and final spot by four points over a Bruisers team that has outscored them by 58.62 on the season. That is the whole bubble, and it is going to move every Sunday between now and December.
At the other end, the model has Hope is Coming at 14 percent and House of Wenke at 8. The Commissioner's research says the real numbers are lower than that.
ODDS AND ENDS
Tyler Shough started at quarterback for the Fellowship and finished with minus 0.16. Patrick Mahomes was on a bye, so to be fair this was not a choice between Shough and Mahomes. It was a choice between Shough and Jalen Hurts, who scored 13.0 on the bench. Second straight loss, still second in the league in points scored, and I have officially run out of fresh ways to write the same sentence.
Old School O'Shea won by 71.06, the largest margin of the week and the second largest of the season behind the 74.6-point beating the Wolfhounds handed out in Week 1. Isaiah Likely 32.4 out of the tight end slot, Bucky Irving 31.5, Spencer Shrader 21.0 at kicker, and Jacoby Brissett starting at 25.28 over Kyler Murray's 18.26. Two straight wins and a plus 45.30 differential on a team the standings have eighth. Somebody is going to draw them in November and regret it.
Parker Washington scored 30.4 out of Scalabrine's flex, which I would guess was not the plan in August. Trevor Lawrence put up 21.74 on that same bench while Dak Prescott started for 12.64, so it was not a perfect afternoon. Three roster moves all season and a 3-2 record anyway.
Hope is Coming scored 129.96 and lost. That total would have beaten six other teams in this league on Sunday. Instead it ran into Scalabrine's 140.24 and became a fourth straight defeat. There is nothing to coach there. That is just the schedule reaching into your pocket.
CKWade03's 164.4 was the highest total of the week and the second highest anybody has posted all season, behind only the 191.66 the Wolfhounds opened with in Week 1. A.J. Brown is still on injured reserve. Whenever that receiver comes back, this roster gets better without anybody making a phone call, which is an unusual thing to be able to say in October.
MY FAVORITE TO WIN IT ALL
The question came down from the office and I am answering it straight, without hedging it into uselessness.
"The Rise of Kraemerica. Write it down and hold me to it."
Four reasons, in order of how much I believe them.
One, the resume. 4-1, and the best win any team in this league owns is Sunday's 157.66 over the Irish Wolfhounds, who still lead the league in points scored by fourteen points. You do not have to project anything to like that. It already happened.
Two, the quarterback. Jayden Daniels went for 32.26 and has been the steadiest weekly producer at the position all season. In a league where the Fellowship has started Tyler Shough twice, CKWade03 is getting 8.3 from Sam Darnold, and Old School cycled through four different starters in three weeks, having one quarterback you never think about is worth more than anything sitting on the waiver wire.
Three, the restraint. Four roster moves in five weeks. The only teams near that number are Scalabrine at three and the Bruisers at four. This roster came out of the draft correct, and in this league a correct draft is rarer than a good trade.
Four, the depth. Ashton Jeanty, Aaron Jones, Alvin Kamara, TreVeyon Henderson and Ollie Gordon II in the backfield, with Travis Etienne Jr. still on injured reserve and due back at some point. Nobody else in this league carries that kind of insurance at the position that breaks the most.
The honest caveat, because I would rather print it than have one of you find it: Kraemerica has faced the fourth-lightest schedule in the league and the plus 74.72 differential is third, not first. If I am wrong about this, it will be because CKWade03 solved the quarterback position and ran away with the thing on the strength of the best differential in the league, or because the Wolfhounds were the better team all along and Sunday was four bye weeks wearing a trench coat.
And the one I am burying. I called Bridge Four my dark horse in August and I rode it through September while the scores said otherwise. On Sunday they put up 89.2, the lowest total in the league, with fifteen roster moves behind them and a minus 88.68 differential. I am not retracting that take. I am burying it, and I will not be attending the service.
POWER RANKINGS · WEEK 5
Forward-looking, as always. This is the order I would rather own these rosters for the next nine weeks, not the order the standings happen to have them in this morning.
1
KraemericaMy pick to win the whole thing, and I am not going to spend this slot arguing with myself about it. 157.66 against the team that leads this league in points scored. Jayden Daniels at 32.26. Four roster moves in five weeks. The best combination of record, roster and restraint anybody has put together.
4-1
2
CKWadeLeads the league in point differential at plus 128.40 and sits fifth in the standings. Gibbs 37.7, Watson 32.3, Nabers 29.1, and a 164.4 that nobody else came within four points of. The only thing between this roster and the top of this list is the 8.3 his quarterback scored.
3-2
3
WolfhoundsStill first in the league at 666.56 points, and the first loss of the season arrived with Kenneth Walker, Xavier Worthy, Travis Kelce and Emmett Johnson all on bye. They put up 128.24 anyway, which was seventh in a week the league averaged 129.07. Down two spots for the loss and not one more.
4-1
4
ScalabrineThree roster moves all year. Three. Parker Washington 30.4 out of the flex, Bowers 23.0, Egbuka 17.2, and a 140.24 that cleared the best losing score of the week. Nothing here is loud and the differential is only plus 5.82, but a 3-2 record built without touching the wire is a draft that was right in September.
3-2
5
BruisersFifth in points scored, seventh in the standings, and the gap between those two facts is 679.94 points allowed, the most any team in this league has faced. Puka 37.7, Josh Allen 30.5, Evans 26.3. This is the best 2-3 team I have covered in years and the model has them at 48 percent for a reason.
2-3
6
FellowshipSecond in the league in points scored and losers of two in a row. The quarterback they started on Sunday finished with negative points while Jalen Hurts sat on the bench with 13.0. There is a very good football team in here and an owner working hard to keep it a secret.
3-2
7
Old School160.26 and a 71.06-point win, the largest margin of the week. Likely 32.4, Bucky Irving 31.5, and Brissett started correctly at 25.28 over Kyler Murray's 18.26. Two straight wins and the only team at 2-3 with a positive point differential. Moving up every week from here.
2-3
8
HaHaThree straight wins and a point differential of minus 5.90, which is the most precarious combination in the league. The 107.8 on Sunday was ninth best and it was enough only because Zaddy scored 91.96. Holding the last playoff spot at 52 percent with a better roster four points behind them.
3-2
9
ZaddyDrake Maye scored 39.46, the highest individual total of the week, and the team scored 91.96, the second lowest. Seven running backs on the roster produced 14.5 points between the starters and the bench. The quarterback is a weekly advantage. Everything attached to him is a coin flip.
2-3
10
Bridge Four89.2, the lowest score of the week, with CeeDee Lamb at 2.9 and DK Metcalf at 5.3. Fifteen roster moves, tied for most in the league, and a differential of minus 88.68. Saquon Barkley's absence explains part of this. The other fifteen explanations are on the transaction log.
2-3
11
Hope is ComingScored 129.96 and lost, which is the cruelest sentence in this column. Warren 36.8, Jefferson 18.8. Four-game losing streak, minus 116.80 on the year, fifteen roster moves, and a Commissioner-supplied statistic saying nobody has ever won this league from a 1-4 start. The defending champion should be answering the phone, not working the wire.
1-4
12
House of Wenke491.88 points, last in the league, and a 119.82 that was perfectly respectable against the week's fourth-highest score. Stafford 27.32, Kyren 19.6, Swift 17.3. The lineup card is finally right and the points still are not there. At 1-4 the honest move is to sell the backfield for something that catches passes.
1-4
Nobody is unbeaten, nobody is eliminated except by precedent, and eight of you are sitting in the exact statistical neighborhood that has produced most of the hardware in this building. Two teams should be selling and ten of you should be calling them. Week 6 is Sunday. Answer your phones.
You made it to the end · Here is your reward
Live look at your correspondent filing from the Florida Keys. Cold Corona, warmer water, a pelican who has not once questioned my power rankings. Nine weeks left in your season. I am living like a beast.
Chet McNulty has covered the Basement League since 2012. He has attended every draft, witnessed all fourteen championships, and has never once been allowed to vote on a trade veto.